The 10 Best Coffee Carafes of 2020

There’s nothing quite as rejuvenating as that morning cup of coffee, is there?

Unfortunately, if you like drinking many cups of coffee without having to trek back to the kitchen, drinking coffee can be too much of a hassle. If you want to keep coffee warm long after it’s been brewed, you’ve got to consider investing in a coffee carafe.

Coffee carafes utilize the best technology to keep your coffee hot for hours on end. You can make all of your coffee at once, pour it into the handy carafe, and enjoy it long after it has been brewed. Best yet, it won’t taste burned, off-flavor, or cold.

Ready to enjoy the perfect cup of coffee at any hour of the day, with your breakfast, lunch, or dinner? There are lots of excellent coffee carafes out there, but we happen to love the Bodum Columbia Thermal French Press Coffee Maker.

In this article, we’ll tell you why that’s our top pick when it comes to the best coffee carafe of 2020 – and we will give you helpful recommendations for others that you can consider.

Best Coffee Carafes

Product NamePriceCapacityHeat Retention
Bodum Columbia Thermal Coffee MakerCheck Price34 Ounce2 hours
Secura French Press Coffee MakerCheck Price50 Ounce2 hours
Cuisinart DCC-1200PRC Glass CarafeCheck Price96 Ounce12 hours
Cresimo Thermal Coffee CarafeCheck Price68 Ounce12 hours
Pykal Thermal Coffee CarafeCheck Price68 Ounce12 hours
Vondior Coffee CarafeCheck Price68 Ounce12 hours
Zojirushi Vacuum CarafeCheck Price51 Ounce10 hours
Hamilton Beach Coffee CarafeCheck Price96 Ounce12 hours
Hiware Standard Glass Coffee CarafeCheck Price20 Ounce2 hours
CAFÉ BREW COLLECTION CarafeCheck Price96 Ounce2 hours

1. Bodum Columbia Thermal French Press Coffee Maker

Bodum Columbia Thermal French Press Coffee Maker

Available in several different capacities, one of the best thermal carafe coffee makers is the Bodum Columbia Coffee Maker. Designed to make the perfect cup of Columbia coffee, this coffee press has the ability to brew the perfect cup in mere minutes.

Using it is easy too, all you need to do is add your ground coffee, pour in some hot water, and press the button. It has a double-wall insulation system along with stainless steel construction to keep your beverages hot and ready to go for hours. The stainless steel plunger is equipped with helpful mesh filters, so you don’t lose the aromas, delicate flavors, and undertones of your coffee to the filter.

This coffee maker has a durable design with a safety lid that prevents you from burning yourself. Not only that, but it’s also dishwasher safe. It can be purchased in 17, 34, and 51 oz capacities to best suit your needs. With no paper filters or capsules required, it’s an excellent no-waste carafe.

PROS:
  • Available in several capacities
  • Has a stainless steel design with a polished unit
  • Double-walled insulation
  • Cleans up quickly in the dishwasher or the sink
  • Oversized ergonomic handle
  • Safety lid prevents spills and burns
  • Fine mesh filter assembly eliminates disposable filters
  • Keeps coffee hot for up to two hours

CONS:
  • Some plastic components in the strainer
  • Requires more water and ground coffee to yield the same amount of coffee as older models
  • Lid breaks easily

If you’re looking for a coffee carafe that will keep your java warm for hours, then this is one of the best coffee carafes for you. It not only sports an effective design that makes it well-suited to brewing and warming lots of coffee, but it has tons of features to improve its safety and efficiency. You won’t have to worry about burning yourself when you pour any more, for one!


2. Secura French Press Coffee Maker, 50-Ounce

Secura French Press Coffee Maker

The Secura French Press Coffee Maker can be purchased in both 34 and 50-ounce sizes. Either model is made out of durable stainless steel that resists damage and is also easy to clean.

In fact, its three-layered stainless steel filter structure means you’ll enjoy a remarkable full-bodied flavor with each cup of coffee. This screen is easy to take apart for cleaning as it’s also made out of stainless steel. It reduces waste and, when you stack one or more screens together, you can further refine the taste of your coffee.

This top coffee carafe is also super easy to use. It has a cool-touch handle and knob for easy and safe pouring. All components are dishwasher safe, so you won’t have to worry about them coming apart on you, either.

PROS:
  • Available in 34 ounces and 50-ounce size
  • Made out of high-quality stainless steel
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Stainless steel filter structure
  • Double-wall insulation
  • Filter comes apart easily for quick cleaning
  • Has a cool touch knob and handle

CONS:
  • Does not keep the coffee warm for very long – usually 2 hours
  • Some customers report that the filter breaks easily
  • No measurement guides inside the carafe

The stainless steel filter structure on the Secure French Press Coffee Maker is truly something to behold. Not only is it easy to clean, but it reduces unnecessary waste for your morning cup of joe, too. It’s designed to outlast other coffee makers and is easily one of the best coffee carafe thermal options on the market.


3. Cuisinart DCC-1200PRC 12-Cup Replacement Glass Carafe

Cuisinart DCC-1200PRC 12-Cup Replacement Glass Carafe

If you have a Cuisinart coffee maker model CHW-12, DGB-550BK, DCC-2650, DCC-1100BK, or DCC-1200, this is the best coffee carafe for you. It is a replacement carafe made out of glass that is designed for a 12-cup coffee maker.

With a dripless spout and a knuckle guard, this coffee carafe is easy to use and handle. It is a favorite option by homeowners and chefs and even comes with a lid.

Although it is not dishwasher safe, it is nonetheless easy to clean as it has a wide mouth and can be fully opened. Cuisinart is one of the top brands when it comes to kitchen appliances, so you’ll know you are getting a great value when you purchase this coffee carafe.

PROS:
  • Easy to clean
  • Lightweight
  • Equipped with an ergonomic handle
  • Has a knuckle guard to prevent burns
  • 12-cup serving size
  • Offered by a reputable brand
  • Comes with a lid
  • Design specially for Cuisinart coffee makers

CONS:
  • Only a replacement carafe
  • Does not include all the components you need to make your coffee
  • Only compatible with certain models of Cuisinart coffee makers
  • Has a tendency to leak and dribble

While this is an excellent carafe for brewing coffee and keeping it warm, it doesn’t come with any of the components you would need to actually enjoy your coffee – it’s truly just a receptacle for the beverage. The price seems low upfront until you realize you will have to buy the other pieces still. Make sure it fits and get the Cuisinart coffee maker first before buying this replacement carafe!


4. Cresimo Stainless Steel Thermal Coffee Carafe

Cresimo Stainless Steel Thermal Coffee Carafe

The Cresimo Stainless Steel Thermal Coffee Carafe offers 12-hour heat retention and an impressive 24-hour cold retention. It is double-walled and made out of durable 18/8 stainless steel. Not only that, but it also comes with a pour spout that allows for single-hand pouring.

With its user-friendly design, this coffee carafe has an oversized mouth opening so that it’s easy to clean and fill. It can be used with ice and has an outer body that remains cool even when the inside is filled with scalding hot liquids. It also remains condensation-free.

Backed by a one=year manufacturer’s warranty, the Cresimo Stainless Steel Thermal Coffee Carafe is a top pick for your money.

PROS:
  • Double walled insulation keeps beverages hot for 12 hours
  • Durable stainless steel interior and exterior
  • Pour spout allows for single-hand pouring
  • User-friendly design
  • Has a large mouth opening
  • Can be used with ice to keep drinks cold
  • Comes with a one-year manufacturer’s warranty

CONS:
  • Has some plastic components
  • Some customers report poor heat retention
  • Has a tendency to dribble

Although there are a few complaints about the quality of this product – namely with its tendency to dribble coffee a bit – it is overall a well-made and efficient product. It will keep your coffee warm for several hours and has a user-friendly design that makes serving coffee easy and seamless.


5. Pykal Thermal Coffee Carafe

Pykal Thermal Coffee Carafe

The Pykal Thermal Coffee Carafe is a two-liter coffee carafe that keeps your beverages piping hot. It has German-engineered vacuum insulation technology that can keep both hot and cold beverages at the right temperature for 24 hours.

Not only that, but this coffee carafe comes with a free cleaning brush so you can keep it sparkling and shining at all times. It has a no-spill spout and press-button technology for easy, one-handed, and spill-free use.

This coffee carafe is guaranteed to last for years as it is solidly built. It has a top lid and handle that are made out of rugged chrome and is backed by a manufacturer’s warranty.

PROS:
  • Coffee stays hot up to 24 hours
  • Comes with a cleaning brush
  • Has a no-spill spout
  • Double-walled insulation
  • Top lid and handle are made out of chrome material, so it’s easy to hold
  • Comes with a two-year manufacturer’s warranty
  • Can keep beverages cold too

CONS:
  • Not dishwasher safe
  • Only comes in one size
  • Difficult to open and close

There are very few complaints about the Paykel Thermal Coffee Carafe. It’s rated as one of the best coffee carafe thermal because it keeps beverages both warm or cold with its double-walled insulation. Despite not being dishwasher-safe, all it takes is a quick swab with the included cleaning brush, and you’ll be on your way.


6. Vondior Coffee Carafe 68 Oz

Vondior Coffee Carafe

The Vondior Coffee Carafe is a high-capacity coffee carafe that produces coffee that tastes like it was just brewed. It has a double-wall vacuum insulation system that can keep your drinks hot for 12 hours or cold for 24 hours.

It’s a great gift for anyone, as it offers durability and quality. It is backed by a full 30-day money-back guarantee and even comes with its own cleaning brush. It cleans up easily with its stainless steel design and rarely breaks.

The Von Dior carafe is easy to use and offers some of the best-tasting coffee you’ll find.

PROS:
  • Can be filled with ice
  • Easy to make coffee directly in the pot
  • Lid is easy to open
  • Double-walled vacuum insulation
  • Backed by a warranty
  • Comes with a cleaning brush

CONS:
  • Not 100% leak proof
  • Bottom is not removable
  • Not dishwasher safe

The Vondior Coffee Carafe has a no-frills design that makes it a perfect choice for any home. Your coffee will taste freshly brewed at any time, and although it has some issues – like not being dishwasher-safe – it comes with its own cleaning brush to help make up for its few shortcomings.


7. Zojirushi Vacuum Carafe

Zojirushi Vacuum Carafe

The Zojirushi Vacuum Carafe is hailed as having an “unbreakable” design. This unit has a stainless-steel vacuum liner for superb heat retention along with all-stainless steel construction. It can also be purchased in a lovely copper color.

It has an extra-wide mouth that measures more than two inches for easy cleaning. It also features a pinch-release stopper and one-touch pour design, both of which make it easy to use without burning yourself or tiring your hands.

You can keep both warm and cool drinks to temperature with this carafe, which has an impressive 1.5-liter capacity.

PROS:
  • Stainless steel or copper design
  • Has a vacuum liner with good heat retention
  • Has an extra-wide mouth for easy cleaning
  • Comes with a one-touch pour design
  • Has a pinch-release stopper
  • Available in two sizes

CONS:
  • Customer report issues with warranty
  • Stains brown inside despite cleaning
  • Multiple piece lid is complicated to use

The Zojirushi Vacuum Carafe is easy to use, and with two different sizes and color options available, it’s one of the most attractive and versatile products you can buy, too. It’s easy to clean and easy to use, making it one of the best coffee carafes you can buy.


8. Hamilton Beach Coffee Carafe for Model 49980Z

Hamilton Beach Coffee Carafe for Model 49980Z

The Hamilton Beach Coffee Carafe is one of the best if you’re interested in an ergonomic, easy-to-use coffee maker. Not only can this unit hold up to 12 cups of coffee, but it has a no-spill design that makes it safe to pour without burning yourself.

A dishwasher-safe carafe, it’s compatible with several types of Hamilton Beach 12-cup coffeemakers and even comes with measurement markings, so you know how much to pour. It is an ergonomic unit with its angled handle and rimmed lid, too.

If you’re looking for a replacement coffee carafe because your old one broke, this carafe is the way to go. It is compatible with many types of Hamilton Beach coffee makers and will easily get the job done for you.

PROS:
  • Holds up to 12 cups of coffee
  • Has a no-spill design
  • Angled handle is ergonomically design
  • Comes with measurement markings
  • Dishwasher safe

CONS:
  • Only compatible with a few types of Hamilton Beach coffee makers
  • Develops scale easily
  • Breaks easily

The Hamilton Beach Coffee Carafe is another replacement coffee carafe, this one designed to fit a few types of Hamilton Beach coffee makers. Although it’s only compatible with a few brands, it has a no-fuss, no-frills design that makes it easy to use.


9. Hiware Standard Glass Coffee Carafe

Hiware Standard Glass Coffee Carafe

The Hiware Standard Glass Coffee Carafe is an adorable little carafe that has a 600 ml capacity. Although it’s small, it’s the perfect size for an individual or a couple who just want a cup of coffee here or there.

It’s designed specifically to be used with the pour-over brewing method, as it has a cone dripper with interior ridges to help the water move more efficiently. It is made out of glass to prevent heat loss and is equipped with a rubber lid so that it’s compatible with the Ceramic Dripper.

It can fit nicely atop a heat-proof, microwave-safe range server and is both easy to clean and dishwasher safe.

PROS:
  • Perfect for just a few people
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Easy to clean
  • Has a rubber lid
  • Glass body prevents heat loss
  • Designed for pour-over brewing

CONS:
  • Not a high capacity carafe
  • Handle breaks easily
  • Not the most durable

Although the Hiware Glass Coffee Carafe is easily one of the most attractive coffee carafes on this list, it, unfortunately, isn’t the most durable. It’s a good option for casual coffee drinkers who only want a cup here or there but is not a high-capacity unit for people who host parties or drink a lot of coffee in one sitting.


10. CAFÉ BREW COLLECTION 12 Cup Replacement Carafe

CAFÉ BREW COLLECTION 12 Cup Replacement Carafe

The Cafe Brew Collection 12 Cup Replacement Carafe fits coffee makers of several brands, including Delonghi, Black & Decker, and Cuisinart. It is made out of heat-resistant glass and is both BPA-free and dishwasher safe.

It’s also microwave-safe if you need a quick tune-up! It comes with two lids for the perfect fit, and haven has a pause and serves feature.

Its unique design means it can fit just about any style of the coffee maker. You’ll want to double-check to make sure yours is one of the compatible models, but otherwise, this is a product that you will absolutely love.

PROS:
  • Perfect for just a few people
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Easy to clean
  • Has a rubber lid
  • Glass body prevents heat loss
  • Designed for pour-over brewing

CONS:
  • Not a high capacity carafe
  • Handle breaks easily
  • Not the most durable

There are some issues with this coffee maker – namely, that it doesn’t fit all styles of coffee makers and is only a replacement carafe, not a stand=alone product. However, it’s a good value if you love your Black & Decker, Cuisinart, Delonghi, or Mr. Coffee coffeemaker (just to name a few) and don’t want to toss the whole thing to the curb just because your carafe broke.


What to Look for Before Buying a Coffee Carafe

Consider about coffee carafe

Design

Look carefully at the design of your potential coffee carafe. You want not only one with an ergonomic design that is easy and comfortable to use but also one that has a durable build.

Not only that, but there are plenty of other features you will want to look for. For example, you might want to keep an eye out for things like easy-pour spots, dishwasher-safe designs, or even bonus included cleaning supplies.

Materials

Materials

Pay close attention to the materials that your renewed coffee carafe is made out of. The best coffee carafe will have a full stainless-steel design and not include any cheap plastic components. Stainless steel is preferred because it is easy to clean and offers good insulating properties. Plastic, on the other hand, tends to impart a poor flavor in your coffee -plus, some types of plastic are known to leach chemicals back into your coffee.

Stainless steel is not the only option, though – some coffee carafes are also made out of glass, which is another good choice.

Insulation

Make sure your coffee carafe can keep its temperature up to snuff. Whether you plan on keeping hot or cold beverages inside your coffee carafe, it’s important that the unit stays up to temperature as long as possible.

Most coffee carafes are equipped with double-walled stainless steel or glass insulation. This can help keep drinks at temperature for longer.

Period of Warming

Period of Warming

At a bare minimum, the carafe should keep hot beverages warm for 12 hours and cold ones cold for 24 hours. This can vary, though, as some are designed more for hot beverages and only keep drinks cold for four to six hours. You may also be able to put ice inside your carafe, which can make the cool temperatures last a bit longer.

Capacity

How many people do you plan to serve with your new coffee carafe? Will it just be used at home or in an office or business setting?

If you only plan on using this carafe at home, you can probably get by with a small unit. Usually, something that is 32 ounces or slightly larger or smaller – depending on your coffee consumption – will do the trick.

However, if you plan on using this in a more formal setting or for entertaining, you may want to get a larger size. In this case, something that is 68 ounces or larger is necessary. This will reduce the frequency with which you need to refill the pot.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q. How often do I need to clean my carafe?

A. You should clean your carafe at least every three months. Many are dishwasher safe, so this shouldn’t be a major inconvenience. Cleaning your carafe will not only prevent unsightly stains and off-flavors in your coffee, but it will also reduce wear and tear and make your carafe last longer over time, too.

Q. What is the best way to clean my coffee carafe?

A. Check the manufacturer’s instructions to figure out the best way to clean your carafe. Often, this depends on the materials your carafe is made out of as well as whether it is dishwasher safe. Many manufacturers include a free cleaning brush to make things easier for you!

Q. Why is my coffee carafe leaking?

A. There are several reasons why your coffee carafe could be leaking. In rare cases, it has to do with the design of the unit. However, more often than not, it has to do with you not filling or maintaining the carafe appropriately.

If you don’t care for your unit properly, it could suffer from wear and tear that will deteriorate the gaskets or seals. Make sure you follow the manufacturer’s instructions for doing so and watch out for mineral deposits from your water, which can wear down the carafe, too.

Q. How warm should I keep my brewed coffee?

A. Ideally, you should keep your coffee at a temperature between 175 and 185 degrees.

Q. May I reheat cold coffee?

A. You can reheat cold coffee, but you should take it out of the coffee carafe to do so. You can use a hot plate, stovetop, or microwave to reheat it.

Q. Can I keep my carafe in the microwave or on a stove?

A. You should never keep your carafe on the stove or in a microwave, even if they aren’t turned on. A microwave is dangerous because most coffee carafes are made out of stainless steel – and you should never put metal in the microwaves! You’re likely to damage your carafe if you keep it in either of these settings.

Conclusion

Hopefully, you now have the knowledge you need to make a smart decision when it comes to purchasing your new coffee carafe. There are tons of coffee carafes out there, but what the best coffee carafes have in common is that they all keep your coffee warm, full of flavor, and safe to drink hours after it has been brewed.

The Bodum coffee carafe is our favorite pick of all of those on this list, but you can’t go wrong with any of the options we’ve mentioned – or by following our handy buying guide. Invest in a coffee carafe today – and drink up! You deserve to be fully caffeinated, no matter the time of day.

Related Reviews:

Erika Barajas

My name is Erika Barajas, a chef, writer, and editor at twimbow.com. I am interested in food, cooking, and crafts. As a chef, I am very passionate about writing about culinary stuff that helps others in the kitchen. I would like to dedicate my time and effort to helping others make the best choices in kitchen appliances.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply